Your MEME fans are some of the BEST! - Fan Showdown S2E12

2 Mai 2021
149 315 Aufrufe

The first 1000 people to click the link will get a free trial of Skillshare Premium Membership: skl.sh/majorhardware05211
Sometimes the best fans sent in to the Fan Showdown are fans created just to get a laugh. Fan Showdown S2E12 Meme Wars, sometimes the best fan are the ones you spend the least amount of time creating.
Fan showdown how to video
dehave.info/down/c21hm7HQjoKtsmk/video
Filament used
amzn.to/3008Lzu
FAN DIMS
www.thingiverse.com/thing:4553248
SEND STL FILES TO
Fanshowdown@gmail.com
Follow me on Twitter
@MajHardware
Twitch.tv/majorhardware

KOMMENTARE
  • I have a roof vent if you want too see it! In like I live in a 80 year old house 🏠 so if you want it I'll get right on it and ship it in!

    Ender StarEnder StarVor 7 Stunden
  • im a fan of the fan fan's fan fan fans

    Sage BrewerSage BrewerVor 9 Stunden
  • I am unable to always catch the episodes when they all come out but I do love watching more episodes.

    Mephusto WestMephusto WestVor 20 Stunden
  • Seems like you used the roof vent backwards as it would get some centrifugal hybrid action the other way

    Jesse RodgersJesse RodgersVor Tag
  • The quality of your content keeps getting better with each video, good work.

    Vasko GVasko GVor Tag
  • Yeah you should do a showdown a week. And then have monthly, the. Yearly competition with the monthly winners. Imo, you could definitely drive viewers and produce fun content.

    Blanco NiñoBlanco NiñoVor 2 Tage
  • What printer do you use to print these? They look great!

    RitirbaseRitirbaseVor 4 Tage
  • Noise is caused by pressure waves which are directly related to the turbulence created by the blades. Using "a" weighting gives a better approximation to what we'll actually hear in terms of loudness so that's positive! What I'm really interested to know from these is not so much how much air these axial designs suck in, but more the turbulence at the output. It seems to me (and please correct me on this if I've gotten this wrong) is that turbulent flow likely to be fairly poor in terms of cooling. I'm a bit late to the party, but an unweighted SPL measure at the output would surely give a better indicator of performance, would it not? I get that you're using a standardized temperature test but it might be neat (in future) to combine a heatsink into the test directly to see the effects of the chaotic flow around the blades. A less chaotic flow (as demonstrated by those "bladeless" fans as Dyson called them with entrained airflow around the duct causes a much more effective surface contact (coanda effect). I guess this is a bit beyond this discussion (it's all over my head, I'm just speculating based on what I've picked up along the way) but I'm sure some of these smart folks could look into that. Seems that at the moment, we're using axial fans a bit like "spray and pray" shooting in a game, with more physics-aware design we surely could improve matters while reducing both noise and energy consumption.

    Marc DracoMarc DracoVor 4 Tage
  • Small recommendation. On the bottom of the screen when you're going over delta placement you should have the top 5 deltas so we can see if any current tests are close to placing on the board

    Noah CaressNoah CaressVor 4 Tage
  • I've seen those roof turbines all over Blighty... I guess they're a bit behind the times there. ;)

    Marc DracoMarc DracoVor 4 Tage
  • Petition to make Fan Showdown episodes an "every weekday" thing?

    Matt MMatt MVor 4 Tage
  • Let me help with the fan question: if you have fans still waiting... keep making the videos as your schedule allows. It's something to vicariously live through.

    Sir WallaceSir WallaceVor 5 Tage
  • Based on a simple calculation if you keep going at the current rate of 4 fans per showdown you would have to produce 350 additional episodes to make it through your current backlog of designs that you already have not including any new submissions at the current rate of production that would take you approximately 6.7 years to process just your current backlog. You may want to look into upping the number of fans that you test in each episode and possible look into making more than 1 episode per week to get through more of the designs that you have in the que just increasing the number of fans to 10 fans per episode would shorten the time down to just over 2 years to get through your current back log.

    The_KillShotThe_KillShotVor 5 Tage
  • My house has one, as do most of my neighbors.

    Silverwing179Silverwing179Vor 5 Tage
  • i hate those ``fakex `` propaganda shirt

    THEY LIVETHEY LIVEVor 5 Tage
  • Do the Fan fan with just Fs.

    Stephen CongerStephen CongerVor 5 Tage
  • My dude, witb a little time, cardboard box, ton of straws and some spray adhesive you could make a smoke chamber similar to the ones used to test aerodynamics. Loving the segment, really impressed by the concepts

    Digital FungusDigital FungusVor 5 Tage
  • More vids=more happy.

    Rostam OstmannRostam OstmannVor 5 Tage
  • I know your ratings are trying to be more objective these days, but I think it would be best to move towards a 3D spectrogram on the noise analysis. A visual aid displaying the fan noise as a function of spectral density over frequency. This can be done with python's matplotlib... Just a suggestion, keep up the fun content.

    Tanner HollisTanner HollisVor 5 Tage
  • I'm a "Fan Fan"-fan fan!

    Very Boring RidesVery Boring RidesVor 5 Tage
  • in the middle of the smoke sequence, the UAMO does not look promising with how much is pouring over the top instead of getting dragged in

    DisKorruptdDisKorruptdVor 6 Tage
  • i would smash my computer if it sounded like the fan fan though soooo

    smashallpotssmashallpotsVor 6 Tage
  • Someone make a cheese grader fan(apple)

    kestis youngkestis youngVor 6 Tage
  • Anyone else impressed about how well ASS did the job it was designed for? Probably the best smoke test performer yet other than the Tulip despite not making it on the board.

    Zichi the FoxZichi the FoxVor 7 Tage
  • the fan fan fan sounds like any japanese 6 cylinder

    SkittoSkittoVor 7 Tage
  • Could've literally called it UFO "Unidentified Fan Object" haha

    mulymule12mulymule12Vor 7 Tage
  • Roof ventilators have been phased out by ridge vents, like you said. You see roof vents on shingled houses more than steel roofed houses. I used to do steel roofing and a lot of the times we'd install ridge vents on houses that used to have ventilators

    RDK SP33DYRDK SP33DYVor 8 Tage
  • Just found your channel. Great content my dude.

    Velocity NationVelocity NationVor 8 Tage
  • The corner 7-ELEVEn my mom used to work at has one of the turbines on top of it still.

    Anonymous AccordionistAnonymous AccordionistVor 8 Tage
  • Alien fan: The Pentaerola

    Tod WulffTod WulffVor 8 Tage
  • I always knew I was an ass guy..

    ChugalingusChugalingusVor 8 Tage
  • Can you test this dehave.info/down/lItddZrGnIqzsno/video in your future video?

    LoTrusconiLoTrusconiVor 8 Tage
  • One thing I'd love to see tested is if removing the cutouts from the center hub lowers/changes the sound profile of a fan. The "fan fan" fan has an annoying sound and it's possible that having a smooth or curved hub could have a noticeable effect.

    HellishINCHellishINCVor 8 Tage
  • I have a whirlybird (or roof turbine as you put it) on my house. I put it in when I got my roof done a couple years back.

    Mike LMike LVor 8 Tage
  • Can't you just run simulations to see what the best possible fan is?

    Ben PBen PVor 8 Tage
  • Have you by any chance tried ABS acetone vapor bath smoothing? It would be very interesting to see the results when taking the same fan before and after the procedure and see how much the rough layered nature of 3D printing actually affects the airflow.

    MELODMELODVor 8 Tage
  • People are opting to go with the central wall mounted ventilation fans instead of multiple roof fans leading to each room because it looks more minimalistic and slick. Great video though, keep it up.

    Allen TrstenjakAllen TrstenjakVor 8 Tage
  • "yeah i vape"

    Marcus JonesMarcus JonesVor 8 Tage
  • I actually have a fun, at least fun for you, story to tell about roof turbines. Recently I bought one to put it at the chimney of my koke forge, at first awesome druft bin the I noticed the sweet smell of plastic. As it turns out the cheep chinesium upper bearing carrier was made from thermoplastic plastic. It melted and effectively infused the lowe bearing. Now I replaced it with Aluminium an its fine. And here is an surprisingly stupid Idea, eventually it is possible to passive air cool a system just with radiators placed in a chimney ish pipe, put a roof turbine on it and place it somewhere windy. The draft of my 160 turbine is around comparable with the two 140mm Corsair fans wich came with my case, so maybe It is possible. A interesting an funny video is the result in anyway ;D

    TheMaschinMannTheMaschinMannVor 8 Tage
  • that fan fan is dope

    Charley EdwardsCharley EdwardsVor 8 Tage
  • I’m a fan of the fan fan fan.

    thereaintnojustithereaintnojustiVor 9 Tage
  • bro what do you use to make the smoke or vapor? sorry if this seems like a stupid question

    Chazz The_SpazzChazz The_SpazzVor 9 Tage
  • Maybe someone already said, but regarding the roof turbine: you're doing it wrong. It's backward. Wind drives a turbine that draws air up through the dome. In your test, you had air driving down through the dome. When I was a child, most outhouses at state and federal campgrounds had these things, meant to draw stinky, hot air out of the facility. They were on top of a stack mounted to the roof. They were never intended to draw air down into the building.

    Tanana MTanana MVor 9 Tage
  • My neighbors old houses have them still

    Green-Fong!Green-Fong!Vor 9 Tage
  • 8:25 dat ass

    LiVe A littLeLiVe A littLeVor 9 Tage
  • how does it go at a different speed lol, its on the same rotation lol

    Paul MillsPaul MillsVor 9 Tage
  • can you include in the "fan" showdown a segment about redesigning the frame? i assume a portion of the noise is coming from the air interacting with the pillars that hold the hub.

    AmberstoneAmberstoneVor 9 Tage
  • It seems strange to me that the "Fan Fan" output so well. I wonder if there was some unintended efficiencies that occurred due in part to the letter shapes. If that can be discovered, it can be harnessed and exploited

    Jerry RiggedJerry RiggedVor 9 Tage
  • Whirlybirds as they were called ended up being a redundant eyesore on houses. They only work if there is a breeze which means they only work when they are not needed. Houses are built with vents for the attic so when there is a breeze they efficiently circulate air in your attic as needed.

    Resto ThisResto ThisVor 9 Tage
  • you dont see those vents anymore because theyre very fragile and if they get bent in the slightest they stop working the new vents people use is just a base vent with a fan from the source other wise called a maxi vent or ect

    David LaurinDavid LaurinVor 9 Tage
  • I see a lot of roof turbines still

    LewisLewisVor 9 Tage
  • NOw 3D print a chair

    GrayGrayVor 9 Tage
  • I'm a Fan Fan, Fan.

    Mark PMark PVor 10 Tage
  • dat ass

    Greg JohnsonGreg JohnsonVor 10 Tage
  • DOGECOIN TO THE MOON!!!

    fuckin5kanksfuckin5kanksVor 10 Tage
  • Over 1400 fans in the que..... Bring 'em on.

    Smedleydog1Smedleydog1Vor 10 Tage
  • I would be amused if you created another channel called 'software minor'.

    OblithianOblithianVor 10 Tage
  • Is nobody gonna say anything about "the ASS came in with a sound decibel of 49.3 dba", yes I'm childish. That's mild

    Ratheon HudsonRatheon HudsonVor 10 Tage
  • I'm a fan of The Fan Fan

    Ratheon HudsonRatheon HudsonVor 10 Tage
  • Don't give people any ideas, or soon you'll receive the Specialized Hi Intensity Thing

    KatanaBartKatanaBartVor 10 Tage
  • Wow the UAMO (or nipple fan) seems great for creating that "smoke-filled room" effect...

    Lo-Res GamerLo-Res GamerVor 10 Tage
  • You don't see roof ventilators because manufacturers are jerks. It should be there. It's literally a step they skipped on your house and still charged you for it. I bet your attic is hot AF too.

    freedustinfreedustinVor 10 Tage
  • Long story short, modern build science suggests that vented attics/homes are no longer considered efficient

    Vincent UribeVincent UribeVor 10 Tage
  • Would you ever build housings for graphics cards? I bet you can whip up some sweet looking parts

    Nathan GibsonNathan GibsonVor 10 Tage
  • I think I may have found some GPU!! On New Egg, there are a ton of Quadro cards

    Marc AhoyMarc AhoyVor 10 Tage
  • I can't get enough fan showdown. It's such a simple concept and I don't know why but I could watch it all day.

    David TDavid TVor 10 Tage
  • Am I the only one who wants to see the smoke come in tangentially to see how much suck the fans have?

    Danilo SoaresDanilo SoaresVor 10 Tage
  • I want to send you a fan design, but I need the dimensions for the mounting holes mainly because it uses a case. If you can tell me the dimensions, I'll make it and send it to you. Let's teach these noobs what is a noisy fan

    Rafa AlmenaraRafa AlmenaraVor 10 Tage
  • The act of heat rising out of your attic is what makes your "roof turbines" spin. Just like a fire carrys away ash straight up into the air.

    Stuart ThomosonStuart ThomosonVor 10 Tage
  • awesome smoke rig, looks like you have an awesome flow coming out of there.

    NoobNoobVor 10 Tage
  • At some point it might be worth choosing an arbitrary level of cooling performance and deeming it "adequate", and sorting the adequate fans by noise level.

    Keith DuthieKeith DuthieVor 10 Tage
  • Could you potentially apply the Venturi effect to A fan to increase cooling potential?

    SenefinSenefinVor 10 Tage
  • I need a cool fan after than song, wow what a banging track!

    NethiuzNethiuzVor 10 Tage
  • "Fan Fan The Fan Fan"

    TauTauVor 11 Tage
    • "Fan The Fan Fan Fan"

      TauTauVor 11 Tage
  • Love the videos, what is the 3D printer that you are using in the background? I've been looking to upgrade mine and I've seen a lot of those and I'm not quite sure which one it is

    SmittyDog34SmittyDog34Vor 11 Tage
  • Have you tried making a fan that pulls rather than push air.

    markuksmarkuksVor 11 Tage
  • first one of these I've ever seen, and the results are genuinely interesting. kinda want this to get more popular just to leverage more crowdsourcing towards just making high performance AND aesthetically pleasing fan designs. technically don't even need to have access to a printer, just the ability to make an STL...

    OtterOtterVor 11 Tage
  • dude, whole food plant based, low fat died would be a charm for you

    TRe' CooLTRe' CooLVor 11 Tage
  • Can I send an .ipt file for the fan ?

    3NTR3NTRVor 11 Tage
    • I dont have Inventor so i wouldnt be able to open this file, can you save it as a .stp if so i can work with that.

      Major HardwareMajor HardwareVor 11 Tage
  • I was kinda expecting the blue thing on the left to be a fan as well.

    nosdregamonnosdregamonVor 11 Tage
  • This is the first time I've noticed that the fan mount is just a helping hands. Love it.

    d3j4v00d3j4v00Vor 11 Tage
  • Man that The Fan Fan fan can really fan.

    d3j4v00d3j4v00Vor 11 Tage
  • Why does your smoke fan music choices always reminds me of Beyblade.

    GhostlyGhostlyVor 11 Tage
  • Were you singing the A-team at beginning?

    ToucheToucheVor 11 Tage
    • i can neither confirm or deny this

      Major HardwareMajor HardwareVor 11 Tage
  • I just passed by a roof ventilator

    mixmaster jayonmixmaster jayonVor 11 Tage
  • Meme Fans and Meme Coins, what a time to be alive..

    InternetspaceshipsInternetspaceshipsVor 11 Tage
  • For the first few episodes, there were sweeping changes to the top 5 every episode. Now, changes to the top 5 are rare.

    Timothy ChapmanTimothy ChapmanVor 11 Tage
  • The Roof one sounds nice.

    Azim AlifAzim AlifVor 11 Tage
  • I wonder how much the rankings would change if it was ascending based on delta by max dB? That would tell you which fans cooled the most efficiently without making too much noise.

    TooShortPlancksTooShortPlancksVor 11 Tage
  • Roof turbines actually make things worse for your attic.

    JellyJoneseyJellyJoneseyVor 11 Tage
  • Keep 'em coming, I like the fan showdown!

    Big BullBig BullVor 11 Tage
  • Who else thought the vase was one of the fans?

    Chooch inc.Chooch inc.Vor 11 Tage
  • I could go for weekly showdowns no problem

    rhadiemrhadiemVor 11 Tage
  • well thats it I'm a fan-fan fan fan now

    TrifeTrifeVor 11 Tage
  • We call them whirlybirds around here, ridge vents happened to them. My house still has them

    Paul HopkinsPaul HopkinsVor 11 Tage
  • Not sure if its been mentioned, but what about instead of a blade with built in velocity stack, would a velocity stack attached to the housing make a difference? like a modest 2-3" tall stack vs a comical 6-8" stack bolted to the shroud? to potentially boost air moving capabilities? or at least for some chuckles

    Collin BalkoCollin BalkoVor 11 Tage
  • 1400 fans in queue...yea, I'm never getting on. I've submitted one already that turns the 120mm fan into a 140mm fan. I have two more designs ready to go that one works on creating non uniform laminar flow, and the other is based on the Fibonacci spiral but on 3 planes at once.

    James M.James M.Vor 11 Tage
  • The roof turbines were found to be much less efficient than ridge vents as they left hot spots and uneven cooling. The ridge vent gives a laminar air flow that draws fresh air from the soffit vents and pulls it along the bottom of the roof all the way to the top. This not only cools the roof, but it also dries the under layment in humid environments or at times when the roof is seeing condensation.

    James M.James M.Vor 11 Tage
  • i think i'm crazy but did you put the roof vent the wrong way round?

    heavytrikeheavytrikeVor 11 Tage
  • Turn the roof vent one around and it will work like it supposed too… you had the flow reversed.

    David simmonsDavid simmonsVor 11 Tage
DEhave